| James Simkins (1956-58) | Doug Suddith (1983-84) | Frank Salvatore (2008-09) |
| Livingston Stallings (1958-59) | Steve Redd (1984-85) | Jim Comer (2009-10) |
| John Baylock (1959-61) | Dennis Boucher (1985-86) | Ben St. John (2010-11) |
| Burke Taylor (1961-62) | Ed Muiller (1986-87) | Joe Judd (2011-12) |
| Murray Fitterman (1962-63) | Ken Wooten (1987-88) | Maureen Comer (2012-13) |
| Robert Ward (1963-64) | Lloyd Grubb (1988-89) | Doug Foster (2013-14) |
| Chris Baker (1964-65) | John McCotter (1989-90) | Brian Westcott (2014-15) |
| Elbert Mallard (1965-66) | Larry Wallace (1990-91) | Jack Lang (2015-16) |
| Harry Vatz (1966-67) | Bob Whitley (1991-92) | Dev Lippitt (2016-17) |
| Cedric Boyd (1967-68) | Don Brinkley (1992-93) | Jan Snyder (2017-18) |
| Ed Cella (1968-69) | L.M. Lancaster (1993-94) | Norma Judd (2018-19) |
| Lynn Kelso (1969-70) | Bill McClinton (1994-95) | Norma Judd (2019-20) |
| Louis Steinberg (1970-71) | Terry Murphy (1995-96) | Norma Judd (2020-21) |
| William Glover (1971-72) | Henry Martin (1996-97) | Jim Comer (2021-22) |
| John Green (1972-73) | Chris Kelso (1997-98) | Gary Todd (2022-23) |
| Jack Taylor (1973-74) | Fred Sikes (1988-89) | Dennis Pymm (2023-24) |
| Ken Margolis (1974-75) | Al Mack (1999-00) | |
| Abbott Weatherly (1975-76) | Jeff Williams (2000-01) | |
| Bill Evans (1976-77) | Craig McCurry (2001-02) | |
| Fred Long (1977-78) | Henry Martin (2002-03) | |
| Jimmy Shine (1978-79) | Frank Court (2003-04) | |
| Ellis Nelson (1979-80) | Dave McCracken (2004-05) | |
| Mel Tabler (1980-81) | Frankie Alcock (2005-06) | |
| Dan Stallings (1981-82) | Len Long (2006-07) | |
| Calvin Stokes (1982-83) | Rich Daniels (2007-08) | |
